Billy the Kid Returns(1938) After Pat Garrett (Wade Boteler) kills Billy the Kid (Roy Rogers), Billy's look-alike (also played by Roy Rogers) arrives and is mistaken for him. Roy Rogers, Smiley Burnette, Lynne Roberts, Mary Hart, Morgan Wallace, Fred Kohler, Sr., Wade Boteler, Edwin Stanley, Horace Murphy, Joseph Crehan, Robert Emmett Keane, Director: Joe Kane.